This article was originally published on Forbes.
User acquisition within the mobile landscape is highly competitive, and media-buying agencies are always under pressure to perform for their clients. However, agencies can become complacent, which leads to underperformance on campaigns — click-through rates dropping and user acquisition costs rising. A stagnating media-buying initiative is ultimately costing the marketer considerable sums of the budget. How do you reset the cycle of agency underperformance? Introducing: “bake-offs” — agency versus agency competitions designed to increase digital media performance for brands in both the short- and long-term.
High stakes, high pressure. Bake-off-style agency competitions offer marketers a way to generate greater performance and transparency across their digital media ad campaigns. These head-to-head competitions between two or more agency teams (internal or external) can reap greater benefits than simply an uptick in performance. They can also lead to better communication and relationships between brands and agencies that provide value for the long run.
For instance, a brand could match a new potential agency with a current, well-performing agency and ask the two teams to acquire the highest-quality iOS and Android users for 30 days. Each agency will then have the opportunity to showcase their expertise in strategy, planning and execution to achieve a set target and reap the client rewards based on performance.
Structuring Your Bake-Off
Once you’ve selected your agency teams for the competition, set your ground rules and goals. It should be very clear which metrics and performance results you’re using to evaluate performance among your agencies. For instance, performance can be measured on return on advertising spend (ROAS), volume, click-through rates or other key performance indicators (KPIs).
Also, set the frequency and transparency of communication on results between your agencies to ensure consistency and to remove bias between them. We recommend exchanging metrics twice a week, such as Tuesdays and Fridays, to ensure all parties are informed of performance.
Competition Ground Rules
Your bake-off should have a limited period of time to run, such as 30 days, in order to generate return quickly for evaluating performance. Set a goal for spend, as well. For instance, a budget of $100,000 per partner with the requirement of spending 90% of the budget within the timeframe will demonstrate an ability to drive scale and volume. You can also distinguish how you’d like the budget set between platforms and which types of ads to test (e.g., display versus rewarded video).
To create a level playing field, seed your agencies with a fresh account, as well as the same creative and audiences at the start of the campaign. After the first day, allow your agencies to optimize creative and audiences separately to gauge ability.
Maintain transparency between your competitors by distributing performance reports across the teams twice weekly, such as click-through rates, install rates and revenue generated, but do not share creative or other best practices. Communication of results through the campaign is a motivator for driving greater performance.
You guessed it — winner takes all, gladiator style! The outperforming agency with the highest net profit driven by their media buying campaign in this competition will gain access to the brand’s accounts and acquisition budget going forward — clear and simple.
What Brands Can Expect To Gain
Bake-offs will generate best practices of each agency in developing creatives, and the winning creative concepts and new variations will seed into campaigns. This will further reduce spend on non-converting ad creatives.
Too many cooks in the kitchen? An additional, unexpected benefit for advertisers is that the process will make transitioning from managed to self-service campaigns far easier, thus trimming down overhead to run campaigns.
Sign Up to Our Creative Marketplace Today